Explore
For Enterprise
Join for Free
Log In

Arts and Humanities
Business
Computer Science
Data Science
Information Technology
Health
Math and Logic
Personal Development
Physical Science and Engineering
Social Sciences
Language Learning
Degrees
Certificates

Explore all of Coursera

Browse
Search
For Enterprise
Log In
Join for Free

The Classical Growth Models of Adam Smith and Thomas Malthus

Loading...

Strategic Business Management - Macroeconomics

University of California, Irvine

4.9 (29 ratings) | 4K Students Enrolled

This course weds business strategy with the principles of macroeconomics. It offers valuable a powerful toolbox together with cases and lessons across all major functions of business, management, from finance, operations management, and marketing to human resource management, organizational behavior, statistics, and, of course, business strategy.

Reviews

4.9 (29 ratings)

5 stars
26 ratings
4 stars
2 ratings
3 stars
1 ratings

From the lesson

Growth in the Developed and Developing Worlds

Overview of the Four Wheels of Growth7:01

The Four Wheels of Growth in Detail7:21

The Classical Growth Models of Adam Smith and Thomas Malthus9:23

The Neoclassical Growth Model and Importance of Technological Change12:13

Growth in Developing Nations4:38

The Quantity and Quality of Human Resources6:37

The Blessing and Sometimes Curse of Natural Resources6:02

The Importance of Capital Formation and Technological Change5:14

Development Strategies To Break The Vicious Cycle of Poverty6:40

Taught By

Dr. Peter Navarro
Professor

Transcript

[MUSIC]

In our last module we looked at the four wheels of growth upon

which a nation's engine of economic growth rides.

Human resources, natural resources, rate of capital formation, and

its technological advancement.

Let's turn now to a discussion of the relative importance of

each of these wheels, and here there is much controversy.

For example, some economists and policymakers insist that the growth

process is all about increasing capital investment while others advocate measures

to stimulate research and development, and thereby spur technological change.

Still a third group emphasis the role of a better educated workforce

as a solution to any nation's growth roles.

Better understand this controversy,

it is useful to trace the history of growth theory.

Early classical economist, like Adam Smith and

Thomas Malthus, stressed a critical role of land

in economic growth during the 18th century and early 19th century.

For example, in his path breaking book The Wealth of Nations, published in 1776,

Adam Smith provided the first handbook of economic development.

Smith's treatise began with a hypothetical idyllic age in which land

was freely available to all, and there was not as yet any capital accumulation.

With land freely available, people simply spread out onto more acres as

the population increased, just as the settlers did in the early American west.

Because there was no capital accumulation,

national output exactly doubled as population doubled.

Now, what about the level of real wages?

Well, because there is neither any rent to pay on land, nor interest to pay on

capital, wages in Adam Smith's idyllic land simply equaled the national income.

Moreover, because output expands in step with population,

the real wage per worker is constant over time.

[MUSIC] Of course,

this golden age of freely available land cannot last forever.

So in the next stage of the Adam Smith growth model, the frontier disappears,

and new laborers begin to crowd onto already worked soil.

At this point, land becomes scarce, and

land rents rise to ration the land, among its many different uses,

of course the population still grows along with the gross domestic output.

However, output and GDP must grow more slowly than does the population,

just why do you think this is so?

Please jot down a few ideas before moving on, and here's a hint, the reason may

be traced to an immutable law that you may have learned about in microeconomics.

[MUSIC]

So why does growth begin to slow down in Adam Smith's model as soon as land becomes

scarce?

It's because of an immutable law known as the Law of Diminishing Returns.

While the Law of Diminishing Returns is discussed much more fully in

microeconomics, in this context it is an easy law to explain.

Specifically, when you add additional laborers to a fixed supply of land,

each worker has less land to work with.

This increasing labor-land ratio means that, at some point,

the extra or marginal product of each additional worker must begin to decrease.

So what do you think happens to real wages in this case and why?

Please jot down your answer before moving on.

[MUSIC]

So what happens to real wages is, the land gets more crowed.

Real wages of course decline because of falling worker productivity.

But just how bad can things get in any given nation as the land becomes more and

more crowded?

According to Thomas Malthus, things can get very bad in deed.

In fact, Malthus argued that population

pressures would inevitably drive the economy to a point

where workers wages would be set at a minimum level of subsistence.

He reasoned that if wages were above the subsistence level,

the population will expand and drive ways drive back to subsistence levels.

In contrast, if wages fell below subsistence wages,

people would die of starvation and

as the population fell wages would rise back up to subsistence levels.

So what is the stable equilibrium in Thomas Malthus' world?

He reasoned that only at a level of subsistence wages would the population

be at a stable level, and in this world of subsistence living,

Malthus believed that the working classes would be destined to a life that,

in the words of philosopher Thomas Hobbes, would be nasty, brutish, and short.

In fact, it was this gloomy Malthusian picture that led

to the critical depiction of economics as, The Dismal Science.

[MUSIC]

These figures contrast the process of economic growth in

Adam Smith's Golden Age, versus that of Malthusian Gloom.

On the left-hand figure, as population doubles, the production possibilities

frontier, or PPF, shifts out by a factor of two in each direction,

thus showing there are no constraints on growth from land or resources.

In contrast, the right-hand figure shows the pessimistic Malthusian case,

where a doubling of population leads to a less than doubling of food and clothing.

This implies a lower per capita output as more people crowd onto the land and

diminishing returns do indeed drive down output per person.

[MUSIC]

So things did indeed look pretty bleak to the likes of Thomas Malthus in

the early 1800s, and he surely must have been not a lot of fun to be around

at any dinner gathering or party.

The question of course is, why was Malthus so wrong about his doomsday predictions?

To put this another way,

what was the biggest thing that was missing from Malthus' theory?

Take a few minutes now to jot down some ideas before moving on.

[MUSIC]

Of course what Thomas Malthus didn't see coming in the early 1800s was

the importance of technology, and an industrial revolution that would

greatly reduce the importance of land, per say, in the growth process.

During that industrial revolution,

power driven machinery emerged to increase production.

Factories gathered teams of managers and workers into giant firms.

Railroads and

steam ships linked together the far points of the world into a global trading matrix,

and Iron and steel made possible stronger machines and faster locomotives.

Moreover, as the world's market economies entered the 20th century,

important new industries grew up around the telephone, the automobile, and

electric power while capital accumulation and

new technologies became the dominant force affecting economic development.

In short, with the arrival of the 20th century, it was time for

a new model of growth that captured a very new reality,

enter stage right, the neoclassical growth model,

developed by Nobel laureate and MIT professor, Robert Solow.

It is to the explication of that model we will turn to in the next module,

and it really provides a startling set of insights into the process of growth and

productivity.

When you're ready, let's move right on.

[MUSIC]

Explore our Catalog

Join for free and get personalized recommendations, updates and offers.

Coursera provides universal access to the world’s best education, partnering with top universities and organizations to offer courses online.

© 2019 Coursera Inc. All rights reserved.

Download on the App Store

Get it on Google Play

Coursera
About
Leadership
Careers
Catalog
Certificates
MasterTrack™ Certificates
Degrees
For Enterprise
For Government

Community
Learners
Partners
Developers
Beta Testers
Translators

Connect
Blog
Facebook
LinkedIn
Twitter
Instagram
YouTube
Tech Blog

More
Terms
Privacy
Help
Accessibility
Press
Contact
Directory
Affiliates