Social Conservatives

Loading...

From the course by Columbia University

What Is the Welfare State? A Cross-National Comparison

6 ratings

Columbia University

What Is the Welfare State? A Cross-National Comparison

6 ratings

Course 1 of 5 in the Specialization Social Policy for Social Services & Health Practitioners

In all nations, social policy is a very large public investment. Course 1 will explore the size, structure, and outcomes of U.S. social policy and compare this policy to those of similar developed countries. The course will also probe the values this policy represents and the values debate regarding about how big our welfare state should be— in other words, how much of our education, housing, health, income support, and social services the government should supply and how much individuals should supply for themselves. This course addresses issues of power, oppression, and white supremacy. The course is part of a sequence in social policy that has an HONORS TRACK. This track will prepare the learner for masters-level work in policy, which involves reading the literature, writing concise summaries and probing critiques. Over the sequence the learner will develop a policy analysis that will create a foundation for professional policy analyst assignments.

From the lesson

Does the Welfare State Enrich Us of Impoverish Us?

In this module, we will explain the size, structure and outcomes of US social policy when compared with comparable developed nations and to differentiate the conservative approaches to social welfare

Politics and Policy3:30

Size of the Welfare State5:34

The Structure of the Welfare State9:20

Floors and Platforms3:50

Fragile Families by Professor Garfinkel6:42

Wealth & the Welfare State by Professor Garfinkel6:50

Economic Conservatives5:10

Social Conservatives4:53

Meet the Instructors

John Robertson
Policy Lecturer
School of Social Work, Columbia University in New York City

In the last video lecture we explored economic conservative view.

And you'll often hear in discussions of politics in the United States

the distinction made between economic conservatives.

That is conservatives who think that protecting and

sustaining markets are central to making us a wealthy and

efficient state and creating the maximum well-being to all of us.

There's another point of view here which is sometimes

in conflict with economic conservatives, and those are social conservatives.

And social conservatives hold that we have a way of life,

a way of life that has been revealed to us.

Revealed to us by the structure of the planet itself given to us by God.

That there's a central importance of the family.

A central importance of commitment to the children that you raise, and

it's valid to look after my family and my people first.

And that we build up communities of

endeavor, communities of connection, communities of blood.

They would talk about traditional values like fidelity, thrift,

temperance, discipline, responsibility.

It's not that others in America wouldn't talk about these values, but

they would see these values tempered by other concerns, like need or

equality or freedom of expression.

Whereas from a social conservative point of view,

these are God given responsibilities.

And a strong concern for the responsibility and

the initiative of the individual.

That people have to take responsibility for

their own lives and work out well in that way.

So, as a result, they believe strongly in small government, non interference.

Not interfering with government to allow families and

communities to build their way of life.

Limited taxation, limited regulation.

That religious institutions are central to the building of a healthy society and

that they need to be protected and supported.

And they need to play an active role in the shaping of a society.

The social conservative view is largely that

charity is a divine responsibility given to us by God.

It should be left to the private sector that government does not

do a good job in distributing wealth.

And that when it is left to the charity, it is done in and

in a way that is more satisfying, more adequate.

And keeps in place the appropriate relationships between people.

It should be voluntary and not forced through taxation.

And taxation is viewed by some as simply the confiscation of what is mine,

the confiscation of private property.

So giving alms is the responsibility of all citizens, providing for those in need.

And whether you're talking about a Christian, a Jewish, a Muslim, a Hindu,

a Buddhist, a religious perspective.

This notion of supporting those in need is deeply a part of ones response to God.

So public transfers to the poor, therefore,

government transfers to the poor are only really appropriate if they're temporary so

that people can get back to their self-reliance.

If they encourage self-sufficiency.

If they help people get on their feet and move ahead.

And if someone does not have the capacity to work.

And has no role in creating that problem, then we can think about long term support.

But, if they have capacity for work or if the reason that they're not working is of

their own creation, then that person needs to take responsibility for

their own world and move ahead.

So otherwise we should provide in institutional settings that is not

particularly desirable, will give people what they need in homeless shelters,

in charitable works.

But that the responsibility falls to the individual to look after themselves,

and to take action.

So this push and pull between the role of the market and the role of the individual,

that is very strongly held by the social and economic conservatives.

Plays a significant role in the way in which social welfare has been and

is being developed in the United States.

Explore our Catalog

Join for free and get personalized recommendations, updates and offers.

Coursera provides universal access to the world’s best education, partnering with top universities and organizations to offer courses online.

© 2019 Coursera Inc. All rights reserved.

Download on the App Store

Get it on Google Play