ZZ
This course has helped me refreshed concepts of design as well as learning ways to see and speak about a design. I highly recommend it .

In this course, critique is defined as a detailed, objective analysis of a work of graphic design and its effectiveness. Critique is an integral part of the making process for designers: it’s not just how we determine if a work of design is or is not successful, it’s how we move our work forward. Critique is also where other voices and opinions can be brought into the design process. This course will introduce a lexicon (or vocabulary) in order for you to demonstrate clearer and more considered ways of talking about graphic design in the context of critique. Through this lexicon and a provided Critique Framework, we will model and then practice objectively describing how well a work of design functions based on specific, clearly articulated criteria. By refining this skill, you will enhance your ability to communicate about design with peers, colleagues, and clients. This course is essential to anyone looking to develop and refine a critical vocabulary around talking about art and design, such as: - practicing graphic designers at all levels - future and current students of art or design programs - teachers teaching visual art, design, or related subjects - any stakeholder in a design project that needs to communicate effectively with designers on their team. This course is recommended to learners enrolled in either the Graphic Design Specialization or UI/UX Design Specialization on Coursera to further develop their skills in graphic design. You may take this course before, during, or after completing either Specialization. Note this is not an art appreciation course for a general audience. While no prior experience is required to begin, the knowledge and skills taught in this course is useful only if you have some relationship to design in a professional context, i.e., practicing, studying, or teaching design, or working directly with designers. No specific software or tools are required to complete this course.

ZZ
This course has helped me refreshed concepts of design as well as learning ways to see and speak about a design. I highly recommend it .
SS
The accent of the second narrator was terrible, he didn't speak understandable. But I liked the content of the course and the other narrator as well.
MM
It is a good course to build your critiquing skills and be properly able to understand the intention behind certain design decisions, if a bit simplistic.
AR
Loved this course. It has helped me so much in communicating my concerns on design. Definitely a must for people in design and publicity.
RH
During this course i learned the language of design and my perspective to see design changed a bit.mentors also done a good job.the course is interesting and clear.
JB
A very thorough journey toward the very core of visual communication. It gives you the vocabulary and criteria to embark on an effective and objective design critique.
PC
I have zero knowledge about design but I want to learn it by myself through this course. Thank you for sharing such an amazing course like this! :)
CB
I was able to understand concepts utilized in the designing process of an artwork. It's a great course to learn about the process and analyzation of design.
IK
Overall the course is well designed in terms of broad and depth. However. although the course does not have any prerequisite, it is a little bit challenging for the beginner in graphic design.
AM
I loved the continuous engagement with exercises and peer reviews. I think generally it’s the best way to learn.I really loved this course :)
RD
It was an informative course. I totally recommend it to fellow designing students. its important to earn about lexicons and positive criticism.
DO
It was well structured and every video, quiz and peer review helped the concepts and teachings really sink in. With that being said, I'm definitely going to take the course again and again and again
Showing: 20 of 257
This is the course I wish I had taken before I pursued a career in design! My education and work has primarily been in designing for (digital / mechanical) functionalities, and I have been wishing to become more articulate in understanding art direction and style. This course taught me how to approach looking at a piece of visual design and how to talk about it. Now that I understand the approaches, I feel more confident moving onto making work that consciously uses specific languages of visual design to convey meaning.
For an entry level course that welcomes beginning designers and non-designers, I feel the examples shown and pieces for critique were difficult for even experienced designers. While I'm glad I took the course to make sure I didn't miss any valuable design information, I was a little disappointed. It says in the course description how this course will help during the design process, but I honestly don't feel that was covered. Because the one instructor at times seemed to be mumbling, the text sometimes did not make sense and it was difficult to take notes.
Short course that gives a good introduction to analyzing design elements. This will give you the framework and vocabulary to clearly convey points in your analysis,
Outdated and abandoned. This course is outdated and appears to be abandoned; I don't see any examples beyond 2019 so it doesn't address current issues like the rise of AI in art. Some of the links don't work or are now behind paywalls. The optional exercises didn't have contributions beyond 2022 so don't expect helpful feedback as you learn; I found myself frustrated because of the lack of feedback. I completed a CalArts course back in 2018 when I last had a Coursera subscription and enjoyed it thoroughly. They are very well formatted and contain valuable information. However, because they are outdated, I'm not sure I'd be able to trust anything from CalArts –and broadly any course in Coursera– is current. Perhaps Coursera should list the date of publication for courses so we can be sure to find courses with the most up to date content. Feel free to enroll in this course; you will learn something. But you may find dead links, outdated examples, and vacant discussion groups.
The videos were very clear in explaining the lexicon and frameworks we can apply to critique the design. It also helps that numerous examples were used to demonstrate the application and pop quizzes were available throughout to test our immediate understanding of these concepts. Given also this is a qualitative course, the explanation provided by the instructors in the official quizzes were also very helpful and informative. A good first course to take to expose yourself to the terms and a brief introduction to principles of design and how to use them. Users can benefit from the course especially when they apply them immediately to their surroundings i.e. Instragram pictures/advertisements as we are all surrounded by design-related experiences.
As a graphic designer working professionally in the field for over 15years I found this course to be very insightful. I genuinely feel that I grew a little bit more into my craft after having taken it. There is no doubt that you'll be working with a wide range of personalities in the world of visual communication. Objective critique is an invaluable skill and this course will set some standards that if you employ and more importantly share in your day to day work, you'll be better for it.
This course is easy to follow, very clear, and very elaborated. The teachers are very good and communicates the point clearly and slow enough to understand and digest. Thanks to the nature of the course which is "design", the awesome visual contents showed in the lectures kept me interested all the way and excited to be shown the next art.
This is very recommended for people pf all ages and skills that are interested in design and want to have more vocabulary to communicate to others about a work. I learned so much and hoping to learn more from CalArts.
Besides trying to find some form and meaning in a design of art, the course also teaches to make meaningful connections when you form and express your own thoughts.
A good course in addition to Graphic Design. There are minor problems with the sound, it is interrupted between phrases and slightly cuts off the beginning of phrases, for a non-native English speaker, this complicates the process of listening.
I finished all the assignments and every quiz on time but the course says it's still in progress... I've been waiting for two weeks to have my certificate but nothing happened.
Please fix this :)
This course was excellent, it was a little hard if you haven't study something about Art it can be really hard but at the end the instructors explain good and you end having the idea of how to do it on your own. I recommend it
The only design course that looks at practical real world design, such a WOW course. All the dash dot comma dash design primers never got me anywhere. Thanks so much for this course!
The information was useful but the presentation was quite 'read' - you could literally see the instructors reading off a prompter of sorts. This made it difficult to concentrate and not that engaging.
If you're working in an industry where you have to collaborate or interact with designers, this course is for you. While it was a little hard for me to grasp an understanding of things, I eventually got my grip thanks to both the instructors, especially Randy who began explaining with the most common things possible and then proceeding towards more complex examples which felt like a walk in the park. For anyone who really wants to understand art, this is THE COURSE for you!
Got a new dimension about graphic dimension from this course. Really loved this course. As from India, I could not imagine taking up the course from CalArts because I cant afford the fee. Thanks to technology and internet boom. Special thanks to Coursera. Wonderful user experience.
A deeper lok into graphic design which helps create a language for assessing other peoples work as well as your own. The examples used here show range of interesting works and assessing thier elements was both helpful and inspiring.
I was able to understand concepts utilized in the designing process of an artwork. It's a great course to learn about the process and analyzation of design.
I loved the continuous engagement with exercises and peer reviews. I think generally it’s the best way to learn.
I really loved this course :)
I am really happy for finishing this course. It has great information and I have learned a lot.
This course was a great eye opener as to how I create as an artist. I now have mroe tools. I didn't pay for the course but I worked on each of the lessons with my own prjects to practice. The instructors could have been more engaging, bring the fun that comes with creating. I would have loved to see updated samples as this was filmed a long time ago. The instructors seemed like they were just reading a script. I appreciate the course and will move forward. Thank iYou!